Review: Turkey Hill Sweet Tea
Aug 27th, 2009 by Steve
Continuing our look at sweet teas here at BevReview.com, which started with the mainstream release of McDonald's Sweet Tea and followed up with MaryAnna's Summer Sweet Tea, we've got another to add into the mix. Recently, my wife Amy & I took a road trip along the historic Lincoln Highway, and while driving through Iowa, spotted signs for Turkey Hill Sweet Tea at a small convenience store.
Turkey Hill Sweet Tea is produced by Turkey Hill Dairy out of Lancaster County, PA. The packaging announces the following marketing angle:
Turkey Hill Iced Tea is made the COLD-fashioned way. It's bottled COLD, shipped COLD, and stored COLD to preserve its all-natural flavor and just-made taste. So it's as fresh when you buy it as when we made it.
The packaging supports this angle by noting that you should keep the product refrigerated.
We picked up a 20 oz. bottle of Sweet Tea. It's cloudy plastic, in a tall narrow shape, more resembling something you'd probably associate with a fruit juice. The twist-off cap looks just like one you'd see on a milk carton. Turkey Hill Sweet Tea denotes the flavor with a tan-colored label (they have a lot of different iced tea flavors — Peach, Orange, Lemonade, Raspberry, Unsweetened, Decaf, Diet — each with a different color to set them apart). Below the flavor name is a subtitle noting that this is "Southern Brewed". A photo of a polar bear is superimposed over ice cubs to remind you that this drink is "Cold fashioned for freshness".
When you open the bottle, yes, it smells like tea. That's a good thing! This tea is colored brownish, like you'd expect with an iced tea. No surprises there. So far, a pleasant experience.
As for the flavor, it gets a thumbs up from us. It's pretty sweet, as should be the case with something called Sweet Tea. There's more of a sugar/sweet flavor present rather than an authentic, diverse tea taste (like we saw MaryAnna's Summer Sweet Tea). If you are a tea connoisseur, you'll probably miss some of that tea flavor, however if you are really thirsty and just want something cold and sweet, then you are in luck! Interestingly, the sweetness comes from both sugar and high fructose corn syrup.
Here's what else is inside:
Turkey Hill Sweet Tea
Water, high fructose corn syrup, sugar, tea, natural flavors, citric acid, potassium sorbate & sodium benzoate (preserve freshness)
A 20 oz bottle will cost you 200 calories, 25 mg of sodium, 47.5 g of carbs, of which 45 g are sugars.
If there is any negative associated with Turkey Hill Sweet Tea, it's the experience of drinking it out of the plastic bottle. The bottle opening was a bit rough, and in reality it did seem like you were drinking out of a milk container. Additionally, the plastic had a distinctive smell which seemed to affect the overall flavor experience of the tea. You might be best off pouring this beverage into a glass!
Overall, Turkey Hill Sweet Tea is a smooth sweet tea experience, with an emphasis on the sweetness over the core tea flavor. The taste quenches your thirst at an affordable pricepoint, using a unique balance of sugar and high fructose corn syrup.

Sweet tea + corn syrup = not sweet tea.
ice cubs!
nice review.
Though they use aspartame as sweetener, the Turkey Hill diet teas actually taste pretty good as well.
Turkey Hill Iced Tea is the best. I grew up in Lancaster County and have been missing this stuff more than anything else since I moved to Missouri. I recently found a Kwik Shop in Nebraska and now drive two hours (round trip) to stock up on one of my favorite hometown tastes.
Southern brewed…NOT….does not even come close to any southern brand of sweet tea..Milos, Red Diamond, etc. It does not have a fresh brewed tea flavor. What it does have is a very sweet fruity taste. Please don't brew your tea in Lancaster, PA and then name it "Southern Brewed"…it is an insult to all of us south of the Mason Dixon Line. By the way, I was born and raised in PA Dutch Country. I have lived in the south for over 40 years. I know how true sweet tea is brewed and y'all just don't get it!
Reb, you're exactly right!
This tea tastes like straight crap!
I'm from Houston, Tx. (The South) and my favorite type of tea to purchase is Red Diamond sweet tea. It's delicious. However, when I was unable to get a gallon, I tried Turkey Hill Southern Brewed. EW! Who the hell from the South told them that's how to make sweet tea?! They were very incorrect. If they make other types and people enjoy it, then great, but it's sure sad that they stamp "Southern Brewed" on their stuff and sell it down here. Hope to hell they stop selling it. It tastes like Lipton lemon flavored tea from a can. AKA, crap!